Forum Overview :: Mac Hall Complaints Department
 
capturing my discomfort with the constant excuses perfectly by up with pod people 09/01/2009, 3:43pm PDT
mark wrote:

I really think one of the reasons Achewood is worse now is simply because he isn't producing enough story... and producing too much illustration... I think for Onstad, like most artists, especially ones where the art is largely conceptual (no one reads Achewood for the quality of the illustrations) volume is what allows them to produce great work. A some point he started taking himself too seriously and decided he could only put out big, detailed, meaningful comics...

Imagine how great Achewood would be if it had been run as a daily serial in newspapers? Onstad would have had to file every day. He'd have burned out, Bill Watterson style, but he'd have never written this plot arc.

I can't agree that a newspaper job would be the answer, but something-god-anything that actually makes him keep to a deadline. maybe he should go 100% pay instead of sulking about ungrateful people wanting drawings for free, and be properly beholden to your paying customers. maybe he should just post the first three frames, then the next, then the next, instead of insisting on these 9-frame monstrosities. maybe at LEAST he could stop constantly re-promising and re-failing to deliver on strip timing.

I definitely agree that, failing some herculean effort in drawing speed, he needs to abandon his questionable illustrations and return to his real strength: his variety of 'voices'. it is an outright necessity at this point.

roast beef dying, however? I don't mind roast beef dying. I fully expect him to die ten times (the last permanent).
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Onstad is going way out of his way to alienate us at this point. NT by Fullofkittens 08/31/2009, 2:23pm PDT NEW
    Yeah. This story isn't... good. NT by mark 08/31/2009, 2:47pm PDT NEW
        Achewood stopped being funny a long time ago. by Chairman Mao 08/31/2009, 2:54pm PDT NEW
            His obsession with Chris Ware knows no bounds NT by I need clarification 08/31/2009, 4:45pm PDT NEW
            I agree with whomever's observation that The Great Outdoor Fight killed it. by Fullofkittens 08/31/2009, 5:48pm PDT NEW
                Re: I agree with whomever's observation that The Great Outdoor Fight killed it. by Chairman Mao 08/31/2009, 6:27pm PDT NEW
            Agree/Disagree. by mark 08/31/2009, 8:58pm PDT NEW
                I think we agree more than anything else. NT by Chairman Mao 08/31/2009, 10:15pm PDT NEW
                capturing my discomfort with the constant excuses perfectly by up with pod people 09/01/2009, 3:43pm PDT NEW
                    Re: capturing my discomfort with the constant excuses perfectly by Chairman Mao 09/01/2009, 4:00pm PDT NEW
                    I wonder if sluggy freelance is still updating NT by Weyoun Voidbringer 09/01/2009, 10:10pm PDT NEW
                        you know what's funny cute animals that are violent NT by up with pod people 09/01/2009, 10:29pm PDT NEW
                            you know what's funny cute animals who edit porn on their amigas NT by Sabrina Online 09/01/2009, 10:46pm PDT NEW
                            that's pretty much every strip of achewood right there NT by Weyoun Voidbringer 09/01/2009, 10:56pm PDT NEW
                                No, not really. NT by Chairman Mao 09/02/2009, 7:46am PDT NEW
    So basically I was completely and devastatingly right about Achewood. NT by Zsenitan 09/01/2009, 9:29pm PDT NEW
        You can say that anything is bad and you will eventually be right. NT by Fullofkittens 09/02/2009, 4:33am PDT NEW
            Yeah, but I didn't say it was just "bad." I said it was xkcd for 30-somethings. NT by Zsenitan 09/02/2009, 9:15am PDT NEW
                Ok then you weren't right about it after all. NT by Fullofkittens 09/02/2009, 9:37am PDT NEW
    How shitty is this current arc? NT by mark 06/28/2010, 6:53am PDT NEW
        It's been unreadable for an extended period of time now NT by Entropy Stew 06/28/2010, 9:17am PDT NEW
            log 6/23/10. by up with pod people 06/28/2010, 9:30am PDT NEW
        4th of July comic is worst comic of worst plot arc ever by Arbit 07/06/2010, 4:56pm PDT NEW
            "He's like the Dr. J of murdering people!" by Fullofkittens 07/06/2010, 6:15pm PDT NEW
                P.S. this arc is the worst thing ever by Fullofkittens 07/06/2010, 6:24pm PDT NEW
                    maybe the comic is only good when it's 90% Ray NT by up with pod people 07/06/2010, 7:18pm PDT NEW
                        That's it exactly by I need clarification 07/07/2010, 12:29pm PDT NEW
                            Apparently there's lots of Ray in the FANFLOW NT by Fullofkittens 07/07/2010, 4:11pm PDT NEW
                    Evaluating Every Achewood Arc, Part 1: 2002-2003 by mark 07/06/2010, 7:47pm PDT NEW
                        Please continue by Fullofkittens 07/09/2010, 6:39am PDT NEW
                            Soon -- just got busy. NT by mark 07/09/2010, 6:40am PDT NEW
                                Why don't you make a comic about it....... JERK? *dumps your books* by Jhoh Cause..... 2 07/09/2010, 1:02pm PDT NEW
                            Re: Please continue by mark 07/10/2010, 9:19am PDT NEW
                                Who is pretending to be me? This is like the 3rd ator ever :( NT by mark 07/10/2010, 9:57am PDT NEW
                                    whoever it is, they really want ICJ to check his zombieworld (it's urgent) NT by up with pod people 07/10/2010, 9:59am PDT NEW
                                        It's probably a hot business deal. NT by mark 07/10/2010, 10:00am PDT NEW
                                            ICJ, please check my Zombieworld email by Ice Cream Jonesy 07/10/2010, 12:30pm PDT NEW
                                                Zombieworld, please ICJ your e-mail NT by foogla 07/10/2010, 12:45pm PDT NEW
                    Evaluating Every Achewood Arc, Part 2: 2004-2005 by mark 07/10/2010, 8:03am PDT NEW
                    Evaluating Every Achewood Arc, Part 3: 2006-2010 (July) by mark 07/11/2010, 12:24pm PDT NEW
                        It sounds like this comic was mostly not good for a long time. :( NT by Jhoh Cause..... 2 07/11/2010, 3:22pm PDT NEW
                            The comic is not all arcs. In general, the arcs the weakest part. by mark 07/11/2010, 5:25pm PDT NEW
                                Re: The comic is not all arcs. In general, the arcs ARE the weakest part. NT by mark 07/11/2010, 5:30pm PDT NEW
            The art is actually the ugliest it has ever been, too. NT by mark 07/07/2010, 7:39am PDT NEW
                How can you tell? O_O NT by Jhoh Cause..... 2 07/07/2010, 9:41am PDT NEW
                    HE'S A FUCKING ARTEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEST NT by Worm 07/07/2010, 6:05pm PDT NEW
            July 9th is even worse. NT by mark 07/09/2010, 5:27am PDT NEW
                Please stop being right about this. by Bunyip 07/11/2010, 4:15pm PDT NEW
                    I literally can't wait to see how bad it gets. NT by mark 07/15/2010, 1:46pm PDT NEW
                        I like that his writer's block/crushing laziness kicked in after THAT strip by I need clarification 07/15/2010, 5:55pm PDT NEW
                            Yeah, why not just write "THE END." by mark 07/15/2010, 7:11pm PDT NEW
                                on his own mother's face. NT by Fullofkittens 07/15/2010, 8:33pm PDT NEW
                                Re: Yeah, why not just write "THE END." by Entropy Stew 07/19/2010, 12:57pm PDT NEW
        This arc: so bad it broke the media server. NT by Fullofkittens 07/22/2010, 11:56am PDT NEW
            Back now. I thought maybe he'd just given up. NT by mark 07/22/2010, 1:49pm PDT NEW
                And an entire week without updates. NT by mark 07/23/2010, 11:03am PDT NEW
                    I don't even get that last one by I need clarification 07/23/2010, 11:13am PDT NEW
                        http://achewood.com/index.php?date=05182010 NT by Entropy Stew 07/24/2010, 5:32am PDT NEW
                            Oh good, even more of these idiots. NT by mark 07/25/2010, 11:48am PDT NEW
                                (see today's Achewood for reference) NT by mark 07/25/2010, 2:44pm PDT NEW
                                    maybe we should have a seperate forum for good webcomics and bad ones NT by Sword of Justice 07/26/2010, 12:39pm PDT NEW
                                        maybe we should have a separate (but equal) forum for good posters and bad ones NT by Entropy Stew 07/26/2010, 12:51pm PDT NEW
                                    August 3rd, 2010: Terrible dialogue, Chris Ware diagram showing how a bear eats. NT by mark 08/03/2010, 12:05pm PDT NEW
                                        Re: August 3rd, 2010: Terrible dialogue, Chris Ware diagram showing how a bear e by motherfuckerfoodeater 08/03/2010, 12:40pm PDT NEW
                                            August 20: announces pledge drive. NT by mark 08/20/2010, 4:54pm PDT NEW
                                                "summer" schedule? NT by up with pod people 08/20/2010, 7:02pm PDT NEW
                                                coincidentally... coinciding... with the first non-furry rape comic in months by Fullofkittens 08/24/2010, 5:15pm PDT NEW
                                        October 18th, 2010: Are we seriously still doing this? by mark 10/19/2010, 8:21am PDT NEW
                                            I can't watch this anymore. As a man with a rabbit ambulance on his keychain, it NT by hurts too much Entropy Stew 10/19/2010, 11:33am PDT NEW
                                                * Tearfully drops keychain in trash to sad piano music * NT by motherfuckerfoodeater 10/19/2010, 12:24pm PDT NEW
                                            Holy shit this strip took him THREE WEEKS NT by Fullofkittens 10/19/2010, 12:11pm PDT NEW
                                                and he apparently traced most of it! NT by Fullofkittens 10/29/2010, 5:13pm PDT NEW
                                            Getting back to why the arcs are so terrible by Arbit 10/19/2010, 2:46pm PDT NEW
                                                Re: Getting back to why the arcs are so terrible by mark 11/03/2010, 6:15pm PDT NEW
                                                    Did he get a new day job or something? by Fullofkittens 11/06/2010, 6:19am PDT NEW
                                                        Holy fuck look at this travesty. by mark 11/18/2010, 5:19pm PST NEW
                                                            At least there's no teddy bears jerking each other off in this one. by Fullofkittens 11/19/2010, 5:12am PST NEW
                                                                The Housemartins: when you're too effete to listen to Pulp. NT by motherfuckerfoodeater 11/19/2010, 10:39am PST NEW
                                                                    ~_~ NT by Fullofkittens 11/19/2010, 12:20pm PST NEW
    Re: Onstad is going way out of his way to alienate us at this point. by Arbit 10/29/2010, 4:51pm PDT NEW
        Still reading comments (WHY) by Arbit 10/29/2010, 4:58pm PDT NEW
    Has anyone read the chap book stuff? NT by mark 01/23/2011, 6:47am PST NEW
        I took down one of the freebies by up with pod people 01/23/2011, 12:28pm PST NEW
            Re: I took down one of the freebies by mark 01/23/2011, 1:02pm PST NEW
                savaged by the sophomore slump by up with pod people 01/23/2011, 2:56pm PST NEW
    He updated again. It's about being depressed, poor, and not updating. NT by mark 02/21/2011, 6:07am PST NEW
        It features Ray and Lyle, though: positive sign? NT by Fullofkittens 02/21/2011, 10:16am PST NEW
    Onstad gives up, posts smug letter about how hard cartoons are by mark 03/21/2011, 7:45am PDT NEW
        The smallest amount of fame that ever went to someone's head. by Fullofkittens 03/21/2011, 8:55am PDT NEW
            I decided I'm not done drawing attention to how much he sucks now by mark 03/21/2011, 6:49pm PDT NEW
                Re: I decided I'm not done drawing attention to how much he sucks now by mark 03/22/2011, 7:27am PDT NEW
    Achewood is back lol by Fullofkittens 11/23/2011, 11:31am PST NEW
        2nd strip back is a return to his generally unfunny surrealistic attempts at art NT by mark 12/05/2011, 4:17pm PST NEW
            The hiatus has ended! Help keep the servers on! Please won't you visit our tip j by Fullofkittens 12/05/2011, 8:26pm PST NEW
            Another strip with no jokes, 9 days later. NT by mark 12/14/2011, 4:17pm PST NEW
                I can imagine Onstad thinking that last panel was worth the wait by Fullofkittens 12/14/2011, 5:42pm PST NEW
                Half a month later: an actual good strip! NT by Entropy Stew 01/09/2012, 10:21am PST NEW
        North plays the game by This is Chris's Blood 12/05/2011, 8:10pm PST NEW
    Only written 4 strips? No reason not to give a bunch of smug, insane interviews. by mark 01/30/2012, 5:23pm PST NEW
    Onstad is still going way out of his way to alienate us. by Mysterio 02/04/2012, 12:30pm PST NEW
    Onstad gets divorced, writes about 3 more comics, gives another inane interview by mark 04/14/2012, 9:32am PDT NEW
        I can't believe he thought a flowchart was an innovative idea. by Fullofkittens 04/14/2012, 2:00pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy