Forum Overview :: Reviews
 
XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Jerry Whorebach 12/20/2006, 11:19am PST
There are presently 40 games on XBox 360 Live Arcade, all are under 50MB and all offer a (usually very) limited trial version. I have evaluated all of them and ordered none of them, yet. These are my impressions.

Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved
Almost exactly Grid Wars 2, which makes it I guess the best arcade game to never see the inside of an arcade since Tempest 2000. The trial version gives you a meaty four minutes of play and the full version costs only $5. Everyone says it's the best value on Live Arcade and who am I to argue? This will be my first purchase once I figure out how to convert all of my useless cash money into Microsoft Fun Bucks.

Alexey Pajitnov's Hexic HD
You get a whole grid of multicolored hexes to fuck around with, spin them, combine them, don't worry if they start disappearing, you get free refills of hexes for the life of this product. Anyway, it's basically Who Wants to be a Millionaire to Tetris' Jeopardy. There are no time limits, usually the right moves are immediately obvious, and sometimes you get such a ridiculously obscure combination of hexes that no amount of knowledge or skill can help you. The full version comes pre-installed on your hard drive, I've probably spent twelve hours with this one already.

Assault Heroes; Novadrome; Small Arms
These "action" games are all utter shit. Assault Heroes is probably the worst, it's Ikari Warriors for people on medication. Small Arms is like Smash Brothers with a cast of ridiculously unlikeable anthropomorphic animals instead of beloved mascots and machine guns instead of anything even remotely fun. Novadrome was just released this evening but plays like terrible 3D shareware from 1996, it reminded me of Necrodome even though the only things they have in common are futuristic dune buggies in gladiatorial arenas and a strong assy smell.

Roboblitz
Physics-based 3D puzzle game. I fired it up and my commanding robofficer instructed me to pick up the barrel to begin the tutorial or pick up the crate to jump right into the adventure. I have no idea what would have happened after that, maybe in the next room the designers said they were just kidding and I should pick up the big-titted roborgasm device to begin the real game, who knows.

Marble Blast Ultra
More Marble Madness. Super Monkey Ball proved that this formula has room for innovation, there's no excuse for skirting copyright infringement this closely. Still fun for those who enjoy tedious rolling around bottomless drops, but the levels are tiny and the full version only comes with sixty of them, compare that to the three hundred or so banana-filled boards in SMB Deluxe for the original XBox (which you can probably find for about the same price now). Don't misinterpret that last sentence as an indication that SMB Deluxe is compatible with the 360 because, although I haven't actually bothered to check, it's not.

Lumines Live!
I had never played Lumines before, now I know what all the hype was about. Another meaty trial version, I made it to the third "skin" (sort of a combined tile/rule/sound-set) yesterday without hitting any sort of limitation. Good thing too, because it'll probably take a lot of convincing before anyone shells out $15 for the "base" game and $5 for the "advanced" game and whatever they decide to charge in future for the remaining locked content. Get what's available now like an idiot me or wait for the inevitable bargain-priced special-edition bundle, the choice is yours.

Cloning Clyde
Side-scrolling puzzler. I haven't played one like this since The Lost Vikings Vike Back or whateverthefuck. Full of that embarassing programmer humour involving sheep and exploding barrels and cute little playtips that no one used to stop nerds from putting in games. Hopefully the full version is a lot more challenging than the trial, because I'll probably order it just for nostalgic purposes.

Crystal Quest; DOOM
Two old computer games, one that everyone played to death and one that no one played at all. Who exactly is the market for these? Wouldn't it make more sense to release a popular game that, due to appearing on only one format or something, lots of people never got the chance to enjoy? For fuck's sake Microsoft, you own the developers of MARATHON! And how hard could it be to secure the rights to the much-talked about Atari Jaguar version of Alien vs. Predator?

Texas Hold 'em
I didn't care to learn the nuances of this game when it was called "Poker," a stupider name isn't going to change that.

Hardwood Backgammon
Finally, something I can do with checkers that's more boring than just playing checkers.

Hardwood Hearts; Hardwood Spades
Hearts and Spades are the same game, and it isn't even a good game. A real deck of cards comes with both of these and Microsoft Solitaire, making it clearly the better deal.

UNO
Tom Chick fucking loves this shit, maybe you can join his buddy list?

Outpost Kaloki X
Fun little Theme Hospital-type simulation with plenty of character that plays well on a gamepad. What more can you ask for? Well, all the missions in the trial seemed to lead you around by the narrative as a substitute for meaningful choice in developing your space station, hopefully the full version opens up a bit. The typical nerd will buy this because it reminds her (haha, him) of Futurama, I'll buy it because it reminds me of the far more obscure and unfunny Captain Star.

Mutant Storm Reloaded
A Robotron clone with beautiful graphics, inventive gunplay, and at least one too many unnecessary words in the title. Now I'll own two!

Various emulated classics
Buy Pac-Man and Street Fighter II Turbo for $5 and $10 respectively, then feel like an asshole when Ms. Pac-Man and Super Street Fighter II Turbo finally trickle out of Microsoft's painfully narrow gamehole. You can replace those examples with Contra and Contra III, Scramble and Gradius, or virtually any other combination of available game and vastly superior sequel.

Bankshot Billiards 2
I might have warmed to this one if the trial hadn't cut short my game of eightball after only three shots. Now I have an appetite for virtual pool, but I haven't bonded with this particular simulation either, so someone's getting my money but it probably won't be these guys.

Feeding Frenzy
Vaguely original premise. You're a fish who grows bigger by eating smaller fish. Predators at one stage of growth become prey at the next. Unfortunately the whole game takes place on a single screen, making everything feel cramped and unimpressive, and you never do end up eating whales or giant squid or pleasurecraft. Blame Katamari for raising the bar.

Various PopCap puzzlers
Bejeweled, Zuma and their ilk have been around for a long time and I still haven't given them a chance, maybe I will some night when I have nothing better to do. I assume these all must be pretty good games with typically crippled trials, so when the time comes I'll just pick one and order it, no questions asked.

Wik: Fable of Souls
The grubby-yet-whimsical art design is reminiscent of Oddworld, but the controls are vastly more fiddly. You aim your little goblin's jumps much the same way you aim a bazooka in Worms, and slap the button at the right time to latch onto grapple points with his tongue. Another game stuck in the age before Super Mario Bros when all levels had to fit on a single screen. Not bad, but not a traditional platformer, which is what I wanted at least one of in this whole batch of titles. Maybe the sales numbers from Nintendo's Virtual Console will inspire some?


Hard to believe that's all MS has managed to squeeze out over the past year. I can appreciate not wanting to deluge the casual gamer with low-quality titles, but frankly I think they've managed to cross that bridge anyway. I think the first two Playstations proved that success requires the broadest possible selection at the lowest possible price point, and the consumer is generally capable of sorting the wheat from the chaff all by herself (haha, himself). See you next week when I cover the new release and anything I forgot this time.
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Jerry Whorebach 12/20/2006, 11:19am PST NEW
    Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Quentin Beck 12/20/2006, 12:12pm PST NEW
        Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Jerry Whorebach 12/20/2006, 1:11pm PST NEW
            Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Quentin Beck 12/20/2006, 2:03pm PST NEW
                That was me. NT by Mischief Maker 04/16/2007, 8:47pm PDT NEW
    Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Mischief Maker 12/20/2006, 3:37pm PST NEW
    Microsoft Points: Better Than Money? by Jerry Whorebach 12/21/2006, 12:33pm PST NEW
        Good business model: make people work really hard in order to give you money. NT by motherfuckerfoodeater 12/21/2006, 1:43pm PST NEW
    Why would someone EVEN read that site if he doesn't respect their opinions?!? by Jerry Whorebach 12/22/2006, 3:17pm PST NEW
    I'm ashamed to call this an update, why isn't Microsoft? by Jerry Whorebach 01/13/2007, 10:37pm PST NEW
    Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Johnny Merzbow 04/13/2007, 10:51pm PDT NEW
        I expected another loveless emulation from Digital Eclipse... by Jerry Whorebach 04/13/2007, 11:19pm PDT NEW
            It looks even better in action. by Jerry Whorebach 04/15/2007, 4:37pm PDT NEW
    Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Ice Cream Jonsey 04/14/2007, 1:23am PDT NEW
        Re: XBox 360 Live Arcade Roundup by Jerry Whorebach 04/14/2007, 12:15pm PDT NEW
            Creexul-style post-final edit. by Jerry Whorebach 04/14/2007, 2:07pm PDT NEW
                Suggestion/Hijack by Mischief Maker 04/14/2007, 3:39pm PDT NEW
                    Good idea. I like all of those suggestions, except... by Richard Gayriot 04/14/2007, 4:03pm PDT NEW
                        That was me. You can tell by the hilarious pun name :( by Jerry Whorebach 04/14/2007, 4:14pm PDT NEW
                            Re: That was me. You can tell by the hilarious pun name :( by quenty 04/14/2007, 6:32pm PDT NEW
                                It just stopped. PERMANENTLY. by Jerry Whorebach 04/15/2007, 3:59pm PDT NEW
                                    YA GETS WHATCA PAYS FOWAH by Bodybag 04/15/2007, 7:04pm PDT NEW
                                        I can't return things to Wal-Mart anymore without the receipt. by Jerry Whorebach 04/15/2007, 7:19pm PDT NEW
                                            Always keep receipts. And renew your driver's license promptly. NT by Jhoh Cable o_O 04/15/2007, 8:41pm PDT NEW
                                                He won the 360. NT by Pay attention. 04/15/2007, 9:21pm PDT NEW
                                                    We've revealed why I don't go around winning Xbox 360s. :( NT by Jhoh Cable o_O 04/16/2007, 12:57am PDT NEW
        My first published article. I'm so proud. by Jerry Whorebach 04/16/2007, 12:22am PDT NEW
            The next one will be Jso and me again. ;-; by Jhoh Cable o_O 04/16/2007, 1:02am PDT NEW
    COMING SOON: Speedball 2 by Jerry Whorebach 05/03/2007, 9:11pm PDT NEW
        Re: COMING SOON: Speedball 2 by Ice Cream Jonsey 05/05/2007, 5:56pm PDT NEW
    A quick note by Mischief Marketer 05/07/2007, 10:34pm PDT NEW
        Geezus! by Worm 05/07/2007, 10:46pm PDT NEW
            Free mouse is only an option, it's designed for 2 analog sticks... by Mischief Marketer 05/08/2007, 12:00pm PDT NEW
                Okay! by Worm 05/08/2007, 8:01pm PDT NEW
        Really? Better than Llamatron? NT by mark 05/07/2007, 11:08pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy