Forum Overview :: Terraria
 
Re: Have you played Minecraft and if so which do you think is better by laudablepuss 05/23/2011, 2:48pm PDT
Bananadine wrote:

This game looks like it's less about building than Minecraft is. Minecraft makes 3D modeling accessible and fun, but 2D drawing is already accessible. But can you control things indirectly? Can you build machines? Are there wires or switches or automatic doors? It looks like building platforms is an important way to get around but it doesn't seem very fun for its own sake.

Videos make it appear that the view is fully in the third person--that is, that things are lit up only according to how exposed they are to light sources, and NOT according to how exposed they are to your character's line of sight. Is that right? The picture of the dudes in the penis room seems to confirm that. So there's never a time when you break a wall and discover, at exactly that moment, that there's lava behind it (or just a big cool cave)? You see things coming up? That'd be a shame. Exploration is fun. But maybe a static 2D room made of head-sized square blocks just can't be complicated enough to be exciting anyway, unless there are unexpected creatures running around in it or something--whereas in 3D, an automatic world generator doesn't have to be very smart to come up with a huge variety of interesting forms, some of which can seem pretty wonderful when you turn a corner or knock out a block and blunder into them.

I guess this game is more about Mario-type acrobatics, cooperative combat, and item collection?


Haven't played Minecraft, I'm frankly a little bit intimidated by it after having watched youtubes of it. This seemed easy. No is also the answer to the wires and switches and stuff. As for blundering into lava and the sight rules: a torch or other light source (mining hat, say) will illuminate the area around you plus a few blocks in through solid walls. So you can see where you're going, unless you're a torch jew like I am and dig until it's almost dark before dropping another one. I've found that the enchanted boomerang can illuminate a deeper area behind the walls if you throw it repeatedly at the walls. Like taking sonar soundings or something. This is very helpful.

Much of this stuff is probably actually very boring but for some reason is fun for me. I can't explain why describing the game makes it sound CLEARLY like a waste of time but playing it seems fun. Terraria is nothing like Minecraft in many many ways. The feeling that you're in a cavern is one. You collect lots of items but practically all of your early and most of your mid-game equipment will be made by you.

One other note: in it's current incarnation, beating the game on a small map is maybe a 20 hour endeavor. The large map just adds boredom as you search longer for stuff, as far as I can tell.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
"Endless Manual Labor: The Game" by laudablepuss 05/18/2011, 11:41am PDT NEW
    Re: "Endless Manual Labor: The Game" by laudablepuss 05/22/2011, 9:01am PDT NEW
    The creator is a little sensitive and is already ToSing youtubes about the game. by Worm 05/22/2011, 9:45am PDT NEW
        Hmm. by laudablepuss 05/23/2011, 1:32am PDT NEW
        Re: The creator is a little sensitive and is already ToSing youtubes... by The Happiness Engine 05/23/2011, 2:34am PDT NEW
            Re: The creator is a little sensitive and is already ToSing youtubes... by laudablepuss 05/23/2011, 8:09am PDT NEW
    Have you played Minecraft and if so which do you think is better by Bananadine 05/23/2011, 12:01pm PDT NEW
        Re: Have you played Minecraft and if so which do you think is better by Bananadine 05/23/2011, 12:18pm PDT NEW
        Re: Have you played Minecraft and if so which do you think is better by laudablepuss 05/23/2011, 2:48pm PDT NEW
            Re: Have you played Minecraft and if so which do you think is better by laudablepuss 05/23/2011, 3:02pm PDT NEW
        Update: am playing Minecraft. by laudablepuss 06/07/2011, 3:30pm PDT NEW
            Re: Update: am playing Minecraft. by Unbitter 06/08/2011, 7:55am PDT NEW
                Re: Update: am playing Minecraft. by laudablepuss 08/11/2011, 12:23pm PDT NEW
    New patch adds about 438534 new things. by laudablepuss 06/24/2011, 3:53pm PDT NEW
        Another new patch fixes the two things that drove me craziest by Fullofkittens 08/10/2011, 9:55pm PDT NEW
    This game feels way too much like work NT by Entropy Stew 12/31/2011, 11:52am PST NEW
        Fuck yes by Arbit 01/23/2012, 9:36am PST NEW
            Re: Fuck yes by laudablepuss 01/23/2012, 10:07am PST NEW
                With no small amount of self loathing I crafted a gold pick by Arbit 01/24/2012, 9:48am PST NEW
                    Re: With no small amount of self loathing I crafted a gold pick by laudablepuss 01/24/2012, 11:56am PST NEW
            exactly what I said originally, thread over caltrops is closed NT by sdroa jists 01/24/2012, 12:27am PST NEW
        I take it back! This game is amazing by Entropy Stew 10/20/2013, 3:30pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy