Forum Overview :: Mac Hall Complaints Department
 
Oh wait, I was just on warning. Time to get banned for real! by Mischief Maker 11/26/2013, 7:09am PST
Sadly this won't be publicly viewable, but here is my response to the warning PM:

QC Discussion Forum wrote:


If you're not trolling, please change your approach so that it doesn't look like you are, and be welcome and enjoy your stay.

The warning automatically goes away with time and doesn't interfere with your ability to post, unless another moderator adds more points to it.

Please read the GLAAD page about transgender issues, too.


Seriously?

Okay, addressing your points one at a time:

I said quite clearly in my second post that I wasn't trolling, the people who said "troll" were uncertain whether I really was one, and just as many people were being "Yes, and..." and moving the discussion forward. An actual troll would post something like "QC SUKZ MY DIKK!!!!!" followed by an ASCII penis ejaculating. I was clarifying details about the psychological study I was referencing. QC touches on some pretty heavy subjects and that should lead to some really interesting and eye-opening discussion in the forums. But if these forums are overseen by admins with hair-trigger ban hammers who shut down conversations when people are kind of iffy on whether someone is trolling, how [i]can[/i] it be anything but 90% twee caption contests?

As for the pronoun issue, I will readily admit being unclear on the subject, so I hedged my bets with "his/her." I'm going to hazzard a guess here and say that YOU are not trans and are just being outraged vicariously. Maybe my awkward use of pronouns did victimize the trans members of this forum, maybe it didn't, but you froze the needle at "victimizing" when you locked that discussion. Maybe the trans members are better than pronouns and could have replied, "It's just 'her,' dickhead," then I would say "whoops, my bad!" and the discussion could continue. Maybe they had a really scathing retort that would shock me into checking my privilege and expanding my horizons. We'll never know because when you locked that thread you gagged them just as much as you gagged me. Can you really imagine a hip youngster who's into quirky webcomics saying, "wow, that arbitrary authority figure took away my ability to express myself, I'm really going to examine my beliefs and change my worldview into one that hews better to the authority figures'!" Is that seriously what you expected to happen?

Power corrupts, dude.


My only way to reply was to "report this PM" to all admins, so they might just accuse me of spamming the admins and ban me that way. WE'LL SEE!
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Time for a bit of the old QC Trolling, O my brothers. by Mischief Maker 11/25/2013, 6:51pm PST NEW
    What kind of person would go to the QC forum? by col.schickn 11/25/2013, 7:04pm PST NEW
        Even Jeph hates and does not visit his forum. NT by EVEN JEPH! 11/26/2013, 4:44am PST NEW
    Today, John B. Calhoun NT by Tomorrow, Kevin B. MacDonald 11/25/2013, 7:30pm PST NEW
    How many posts 'til I'm banned? by Mischief Maker 11/25/2013, 7:49pm PST NEW
        real horrorshow. But I fear it's but pearls before swine by blackwater 11/25/2013, 9:37pm PST NEW
    2 posts in and I'm already banned. Can you guess why? by Mischief Maker 11/25/2013, 10:18pm PST NEW
        Oh my god. NT by Eurotrash 11/25/2013, 11:19pm PST NEW
        Think of the gayest possible reason NT by now think even gayer 11/26/2013, 12:02am PST NEW
    Oh wait, I was just on warning. Time to get banned for real! by Mischief Maker 11/26/2013, 7:09am PST NEW
        Aaaand... by Mischief Maker 11/26/2013, 8:41am PST NEW
            Trained lawyer vs. Amateur forum moderator(s) by N 11/26/2013, 8:58am PST NEW
                So does this make sex below your education level statutory rape? by Worm 11/26/2013, 9:43am PST NEW
                    I feel violated whenever you IT fuckers discuss Linux. Mass banning, plz. NT by Mischief Maker 11/26/2013, 10:30am PST NEW
                        *snort* I find that HIGHLY UNLIKELY NT by linux nerds 11/29/2013, 2:16pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy