Forum Overview :: Castle Wolfenstein
 
Oh, RPS. by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/24/2014, 7:27am PST
http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/02/24/wolfenstein-the-new-order-preview/

Not a single word about the save system. But here's the review from Dan Grill:

Yet I have a personal concern, coming from the core of Wolfenstein. Its choice of Hammer Horror subject matter – science-fiction, occultist Nazis – escaped Western criticism back in the early 90s when the industry was so niche. But it’s persistently caused problems in Germany, where each new game has to be extensively de-Nazified.

Perhaps Germany has it right. Perhaps we shouldn’t be leveraging for wacky entertainment one of the most horrible periods of human history. Wolfenstein is very much like Inglorious Basterds in that, however enjoyable we might find the spectacle of the moment-to-moment violence, there is no moral depth here. The forced choice that both Jim and I balked at is cruel and makes the player complicit in it – but beyond the chosen character not appearing later in the game, it’s gratuitous.

I’m unsure whether subject matter this morally-conflicted demands that we deal with it seriously. Half of modern-day Britain was raised on a diet of televised comedy Nazis in Allo Allo and Dad’s Army, continuing the propaganda caricatures from WWII. It’s completely normal that we think about Nazis as wacky – and it’s easy to joke about Commander ‘Death Shed’, up until you stumble across the picture of an actual death shed from Ohrdruf.

Wolfenstein flits between gung-ho war, camp Nazis, mass-murder FPS and torture-horror. Yet it’s not the portrayal but the tone that’s off. By making these fictional Nazis out to be comically and inhumanly evil, the game is obfuscating that it was real, normal people who calmly and systematically eliminated millions of other humans.


(I'm going to let go of the fact that in a game where the National Socialists are your enemy and commit one new atrocity per level, he starts a paragraph with "Perhaps Germany has it right.")

If you want someone to crystallize why some people hate social justice so much, this is a great example. Somebody paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for the Wolfenstein IP at some point. RPS would like them to just let that IP expire. His review describes interesting choices, the likes of which we've never seen in a CW game and he notes several callbacks to the original Apple/PC game. It's the only Castle Wolfenstein game that sounds interesting since the first one. Rather than do real work to counter the fact that America and England are slowly turning into police states, RPS would like there to no longer be any Nazis in videogames. We would also like the barbarians to be removed from Civilization II and white civilians eliminated from X-COM, since really when you think about it, an alien invasion would be the fault of cis scum anyway.

But this really is the perfect SJ ending to a review: a call for other people to stop doing things, to lose millions of potential dollars, all while requiring no effort whatsoever on the part of the person making the request.


the dark and gritty...Ice Cream Jonsey!
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Oh, RPS. by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/24/2014, 7:27am PST NEW
    Carlie Chaplin: nazi apologist NT by The Great Dictator 02/24/2014, 8:38am PST NEW
        It's true by Horban 02/24/2014, 9:27am PST NEW
        Mein Leben! NT by Ernst Lubitsch, To Be or Not to Be 02/24/2014, 9:42am PST NEW
            Heil Hitler! NT by Top Secret's Val Kilmer 02/24/2014, 10:49am PST NEW
                Heil me NT by Hitler, To Be or Not to Be 02/24/2014, 1:38pm PST NEW
                    Heil...MYSELF! NT by Springtime for Hitler 02/24/2014, 7:20pm PST NEW
    Of course a bunch of fucking Brits would want to whitewash history. by Worm 02/24/2014, 9:31am PST NEW
    Re: Oh, RPS. by Rafiki 02/24/2014, 10:53am PST NEW
        It's an argument against all satire in general NT by The Great Dictator 02/24/2014, 11:04am PST NEW
    It's especially sad that the comments are not just a howling choir of FUUUCKYOUU by Eurotrash 02/24/2014, 12:38pm PST NEW
        Oh yeah, agreed, it does look like a fun game. by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/24/2014, 1:35pm PST NEW
    I'm knee-deep in the 2009 Wolfenstein right now. It's... problematic. by Jerry Whorebach 02/24/2014, 3:22pm PST NEW
        Confirming that Wolfenstein (2009) is a boring generic FPS NT by WITTGENSTEIN 02/24/2014, 5:26pm PST NEW
            Even the title is half-assed. Which Wolfenstein is it? Finish the thought! by Jerry Whorebach 02/24/2014, 6:23pm PST NEW
                Raven developer confirms my suspicions in excellent new article on Singularity. by Jerry Whorebach 03/17/2014, 1:33am PDT NEW
        Re: I'm knee-deep in the 2009 Wolfenstein right now. It's... problematic. by Jonah Hill 02/25/2014, 4:48am PST NEW
    So is the author and comments section choking on a mountain of shit in light of by Rafiki 10/26/2017, 5:59pm PDT NEW
        Are we talking about the fact that game journos love cartoon Nazi killing now? by mike williams usgamer 12/01/2017, 8:01pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy