Forum Overview :: Saints Row 4
 
I'm the opposite. Loved 3, hated 4. It felt like an incomplete fan mod of 3. by Mischief Maker 01/05/2020, 8:14am PST
I'm replaying 3 right now and it's just a better game in every way.

The enemies are more diverse with wildly different combat patterns between gangs (Eurotrash use giant trolls and helicopter snipers, Hackers use zwee-fighting rollerblades with giant electro hammers, Luchadores blanket the area in mini grenades, Anime Military uses laser tanks, etc.) while the enemies in 4 are just aliens in elon musk pickups who stand still and shoot at you, but the SUPER aliens jump real high, then just stand still and shoot at you. SR4 at its craziest has you fall from the sky and cause a non-interective cutscene of a nuclear blast, SR3 at its craziest has gigantic emergent battlefields with exploding vehicles falling from the sky left and right.

The superpowers are nifty, but with the exception of downtown the city of steelport just is not designed vertically enough to accommodate them. Plus the enemy AI certainly can't cope with your powers, which is why so many story missions zap you with de-powering grenades at the start. SR5/Gat out of Hell, for all its flaws, had better superpowers with a city designed to show them off.

And story and humor were much better in 3. Depending on the voice you took, your character had a completely different personality and motivations. Whereas in 4 they're basically 6 voice actors reading from the same script and they took out my favorite Boris & Natasha Russian accent lady and replaced her with a boring southern belle. Plus the jokes in 3 aged much more gracefully than 4, Trump was already president when gog finally got 4 and the central gag wasn't that shocking a premise anymore. I really don't care about Johnny Gat and the deep personal motivations driving my supporting cast (Kinsie hates the 50s? Am I supposed to give a shit?) Plus when the premise of the game is the world you're fucking up isn't real, the people running and screaming are just NPCs, and the mayhem you're causing is 100% consequence-free in the story, it sucks all the magic out of a GTA-clone rampage.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
This game is pretty great by jeep 08/20/2013, 7:56am PDT NEW
    But I can't be a transsexual and it doesn't take itself seriously wahhh NT by Yahtzee, who hated Saints Row III 08/20/2013, 8:08am PDT NEW
        to be fair, Yahtzee's a retard NT by jeep 08/20/2013, 8:58am PDT NEW
        Please tell me that a straight male like Yahtzee isn't dinging games because he by Souffle of Pain 08/20/2013, 9:00am PDT NEW
            Watch the vid for Saints Row 3 by WITTGENSTEIN 08/20/2013, 9:20am PDT NEW
    Played for four hours. Just went around collecting power-ups and superjumping. by WITTGENSTEIN 08/20/2013, 10:06pm PDT NEW
        I didn't know I needed to buy this until you said that NT by Entropy Stew 08/20/2013, 11:29pm PDT NEW
            My only complaint is I feel like some of the best moments from SR3 didn't carry by WITTGENSTEIN 08/21/2013, 9:04am PDT NEW
                I was wrong. Ignore this post. by WITTGENSPOILERS 08/23/2013, 11:26am PDT NEW
                    It's not quite as awesome as "What I Got", but.... by WITTGENSPOILERS 08/24/2013, 4:46pm PDT NEW
    I am so glad a game like this got made by Rafiki 08/21/2013, 10:09am PDT NEW
        The Matrix Steelport is just one giant "They Live" reference NT by WITTGENSTEIN 08/21/2013, 10:12am PDT NEW
            You literally get a Roddy Piper costume later NT by jeep 08/21/2013, 11:55pm PDT NEW
        How many times do you see a fail state in that first hour? Or is it just like NT by watching cartoons with more buttons 08/21/2013, 12:01pm PDT NEW
            It's not "Press X to Not Die" so much as "Press X to continue the cool intro" by WITTGENSTEIN 08/21/2013, 12:25pm PDT NEW
            As many times as you want? You could just stand there and not fight back, I gue by Rafiki 08/21/2013, 12:59pm PDT NEW
    Literally the best game I have ever played. You guys got a Steam group? NT by Souffle of Pain 08/22/2013, 10:19am PDT NEW
        Yeah, it's called Caltrops. I am going to join too. NT by Ken Doral 08/22/2013, 11:28am PDT NEW
    Hated it. by Kenji Carter 08/22/2013, 1:04pm PDT NEW
        Did you feel the same way about Saints Row 3? by WITTGENSTEIN 08/22/2013, 1:33pm PDT NEW
            You know what, I did by Kenji Carter 08/22/2013, 2:20pm PDT NEW
                Re: You know what, I did by Kenji Carter 08/22/2013, 2:22pm PDT NEW
                On the topic of difficulty curves and the opponents you face in Saints Row by WITTGENSTEIN 08/22/2013, 2:25pm PDT NEW
                How old is your little brother? NT by jerri blank 08/22/2013, 3:07pm PDT NEW
                    8 NT by Kenji Carter 08/22/2013, 3:30pm PDT NEW
                        I was playing Starflight and Star Control at age 7 by WITTGENSTEIN 08/22/2013, 4:12pm PDT NEW
                            You're OK, WITTGENSTEIN NT by Kenji Carter 08/22/2013, 5:23pm PDT NEW
                I'm the opposite. Loved 3, hated 4. It felt like an incomplete fan mod of 3. by Mischief Maker 01/05/2020, 8:14am PST NEW
                    Absolutely correct NT by Rey Mysterio 01/05/2020, 8:43am PST NEW
            Does it give you anything to DO with all those abilities, besides screw around by with them like toys in a sandbox? 08/22/2013, 2:26pm PDT NEW
                There are minigames framed around the using the powers. by WITTGENSTEIN 08/22/2013, 2:30pm PDT NEW
                Verified. Continue... NT by Bradley Svedka. 08/22/2013, 2:47pm PDT NEW
    GAT V by jeep 09/12/2013, 10:00pm PDT NEW
        Enter the Dominatrix was worth the price of admission. NT by WITTGENSTEIN 12/02/2013, 9:19am PST NEW
    Yes, it's good by Ice Cream Jonsey 04/16/2014, 7:47am PDT NEW
    Does anyone know why that weird creature showed up for one restore? by Ice Cream Jonsey 01/02/2020, 9:21pm PST NEW
        That's Professor Genki! by Mischief Maker 01/02/2020, 10:24pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy