Mischief Shai-hulud wrote:

Bill Dungsroman wrote:

Chairman Mao wrote:

Bill Dungsroman wrote:

If you guys want to duel, I'll wait until both or your reviews are in, and we'll have a simultaneous release so no one seems to get the last word. Deal?

Sounds good to me, but he can't rebut unless he reads mine, right?
My review will be mostly positive, so I'm assuming he wants to make his mostly negative.

Are you willing to go first then? Either we have that, or you guys write independent pos/neg reviews and they "rebut" each other by proxy.

How about they both agree on an identical structure for their reviews like:

-plot
-graphics
-sound
-gameplay,
-(specific gameplay elements like combat, corruption, diplomacy, culture, etc. in order)
-multiplayer
-bugginess
-etc.

They write them in the same order, then you display both reviews side-by-side on the same page with their sections matching. On the left, he said he likes it, on the right, he said it sucks. Simultaneous submission so neither gets the last word.

Dig it?