Forum Overview :: Motherfucking News
 
Re: I'll grant the first, actually, but not the second by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 8:45pm PDT
Senor Barborito wrote:


I'm very, very glad to hear you say that the Patriot Act is a significant problem as that's something incredibly important we agree upon. It is not absurd to bring it up when assessing the degree to which terrorism has or has not accomplished it's goals given Osama has directly stated that he cannot wait to suck every bit of personal liberty out of Western culture just to make it unlivable for intelligent people and the Patriot Act is the start of a very slippery slope which finds the next point on its chart of descent in the proposed Patriot II Act. I don't need to tell you that this represents a significant negative acceleration.


A valid point. Nonetheless, I believe it is still problematic to confuse OBL's theoretical goals (destroying western liberty) with his concrete goals (killing Americans and their allies, and whoever else is in the way), and therefore obscuring the relative priority we should attach to each. Every war has required some compromise in personal liberty, be it through rations or a draft, for it to be successfully prosecuted. The biggest problems with the Patriot act and its future iterations stem from the following:
1. There is no evidence whatsoever that the existence of a Patriot Act would have done anything to prevent 9/11 had it been in place. Since that was the trigger that set off its implementation, it is no small concern to wonder why, then, nothing is being done within the PA to prevent such future occurrences. Rather, the real action with terror prevention seems to be within the already existing mandates of law enforcement and intelligence organizations, as well as the "Homeland Security Dept", which of course requires more time before its effectivitiy as a coordinating bureaucracy can be judged accurately.

2. There is no conditional part to the PA. There is no length of time at which its effectivity will be considered again and its place revoked if it has failed.

3. Worst of all, there is NO division except among the radical Libertarians and the knee-jerk anti Govt leftists with any credibility against this monstrosity. They are all in it together, and loth to be the first to buckle.

Either way, I still think it is a far cry from the Patriot act to any of OBL's goals. We have cultural safeguards at the very least that will ensure that the medieval mentality of an Islamic theocracy is still distant.

It is also open to debate what the Supreme Court plans to do with it in the long run. I find it hard to believe that most of the act could be found remotely constitutional, even as a temporary, Lincoln-style act during war. Hell, even the cretins that signed it are having second thoughts these days...
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
War on Terror may create World of Terror says Rumsfeld. by Fussbett 05/24/2003, 1:20pm PDT NEW
    Re: War on Terror may create World of Terror says Rumsfeld. by Mh 05/24/2003, 6:40pm PDT NEW
    I thought we got rid of terror when we invaded Iraq! NT by The Ironic One 05/24/2003, 6:53pm PDT NEW
    One day this war on terror is going to end :( NT by Col. Kilgore 05/24/2003, 8:43pm PDT NEW
    Re: War on Terror may create World of Terror says Rumsfeld. by Lizard_King 05/25/2003, 3:28pm PDT NEW
        I'll keep this simple by fag packet 05/26/2003, 3:08am PDT NEW
            Re: I'll keep this simple by fag packet 05/26/2003, 3:18am PDT NEW
            Terrorism won when we declared the war on it and passed the Patriot Act by Senor Barborito 05/26/2003, 4:48pm PDT NEW
                Example by Senor Barborito 05/26/2003, 8:41pm PDT NEW
                    Re: Example by Jhoh Creexul 05/26/2003, 10:22pm PDT NEW
                Re: Terrorism won when we declared the war on it and passed the Patriot Act by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 3:10am PDT NEW
                    I'll grant the first, actually, but not the second by Senor Barborito 05/27/2003, 6:50am PDT NEW
                        Re: I'll grant the first, actually, but not the second by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 8:45pm PDT NEW
            Re: I'll keep this simple by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 3:03am PDT NEW
                Re: I'll keep this simple by I need clarification 05/27/2003, 3:50am PDT NEW
                    Holy fuck I agree with you and Fussbett both?! NT by Senor Barborito 05/27/2003, 6:57am PDT NEW
                    I'll keep this extra simple for INC's sake. by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 8:32pm PDT NEW
                        EVERYTHING you say is exceedingly simple, moron. It's in your DNA. by I need clarification 05/27/2003, 9:25pm PDT NEW
                            Re: EVERYTHING you say is exceedingly simple, moron. It's in your DNA. by Lizard_King 05/28/2003, 2:18am PDT NEW
                                Just a nit... by Chairman Mao 05/28/2003, 2:25am PDT NEW
                                    Re: Just a nit... by foogla 05/28/2003, 3:23am PDT NEW
                                    Re: Just a nit... by Lizard_King 05/28/2003, 6:10pm PDT NEW
                                        Yeah I thought you'd say something like that. NT by Chairman Mao 05/28/2003, 6:31pm PDT NEW
                                You're (still) boring by I need clarification 05/29/2003, 3:35am PDT NEW
                                    Re: You're (still) boring by Lizard_King 05/30/2003, 1:16pm PDT NEW
                                        Jesus, you're fucking predictable. And boring. by Satire 05/30/2003, 2:19pm PDT NEW
                                            Doh! I mean NT by I need clarification 05/30/2003, 5:46pm PDT NEW
                                                Thanks NT by I need clarification 05/30/2003, 6:18pm PDT NEW
                                            Re: Jesus, you're fucking predictable. And boring. by Lizard_King 05/30/2003, 11:15pm PDT NEW
                                                I win!! You ARE boring! by I need clarification 05/31/2003, 2:00am PDT NEW
                                                    You fucking idiot. by Lizard_King 05/31/2003, 1:31pm PDT NEW
                                                        Re: You fucking idiot. by foogla 05/31/2003, 3:10pm PDT NEW
                                                            Re: You fucking idiot. by Lizard_King 05/31/2003, 11:48pm PDT NEW
                                                                I need smileys by foogla 06/01/2003, 6:15am PDT NEW
                                                                fixed last quote by foogla 06/01/2003, 6:16am PDT NEW
                                                                    Re: fixed last quote by Lizard_King 06/01/2003, 12:11pm PDT NEW
                                                                        Re: fixed last quote by foogla 06/01/2003, 2:57pm PDT NEW
                                                        Man, you really stick to the playbook, don't you? by I need clarification 05/31/2003, 5:51pm PDT NEW
                                                            As usual, your "arguments" are disappointing and trite. by Lizard_King 05/31/2003, 11:38pm PDT NEW
                                                                fucked up the quotes above. NT by Lizard_King 05/31/2003, 11:39pm PDT NEW
                                                                Fucked up the argument above as well. HA! by I need clarification 06/01/2003, 2:34am PDT NEW
                                                                    Pitiful. Your posts are just getting worse. by Lizard_King 06/01/2003, 12:00pm PDT NEW
                                                                        Re: Pitiful. Your posts are just getting worse. by fag packet 06/01/2003, 9:11pm PDT NEW
                                                                            Unfortunately by Senor Barborito 06/02/2003, 12:12am PDT NEW
                                                                            Re: Pitiful. Your posts are just getting worse. by Lizard_King 06/02/2003, 10:25pm PDT NEW
                                                                                Deep sigh by fag packet 06/03/2003, 3:36am PDT NEW
                                                                                    Well, I'm glad we cleared at least part of that up. by Lizard_King 06/03/2003, 2:57pm PDT NEW
                                                                        You have ONE unheard messages. To hear new messages, click here. by I need clarification 06/01/2003, 11:31pm PDT NEW
                                                                            Re: You have ONE unheard messages. To hear new messages, click here. by Lizard_King 06/02/2003, 10:14pm PDT NEW
                                                                                Mind if I chime in here? by Senor Barborito 06/02/2003, 10:28pm PDT NEW
                                                                                    Re: Mind if I chime in here? by Lizard_King 06/02/2003, 11:30pm PDT NEW
                                                                            Re: You have ONE unheard messages. To hear new messages, click here. by Lizard_King 06/02/2003, 10:26pm PDT NEW
                Re: I'll keep this simple by Fussbett 05/27/2003, 4:18am PDT NEW
            What a pouty child you are by Diotallevi 05/27/2003, 7:39pm PDT NEW
                Thanks for addressing that portion so effectively. NT by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 8:46pm PDT NEW
                    ...and thank YOU for reponding to yourself. NT by Nick Detective... still holding out 05/27/2003, 8:54pm PDT NEW
                        Fag. Keep trying, though. NT by Lizard_King 05/27/2003, 9:08pm PDT NEW
                            Dear Cocksucker by fag packet 05/28/2003, 9:13pm PDT NEW
                                Dear Shit Drinker by Lizard_King 05/30/2003, 1:21pm PDT NEW
                                    Re: Dear Shit Drinker by John Ashcroft 05/30/2003, 1:45pm PDT NEW
                                        "Enterprize"? OMFG clever RFOFLOFL NT by Excited commie shitheads everywhere 05/30/2003, 11:18pm PDT NEW
                                    We Are No More. by Higher Standards 05/31/2003, 3:25am PDT NEW
                And, cunt - by fag packet 05/28/2003, 9:38pm PDT NEW
                Dio you rule by Steve Lollerson 2 06/04/2003, 11:26am PDT NEW
    Re: War on Terror may create World of Terror says Rumsfeld. by foogla 05/27/2003, 6:56am PDT NEW
        U.S. to Planet: Suck our collective dick. by Moab 05/27/2003, 8:04am PDT NEW
            So by Senor Barborito 05/27/2003, 8:12am PDT NEW
                Re: So by Moab 05/27/2003, 8:23am PDT NEW
                    Switzerland? We could be like the Von Trapp family with more dicksucking! by Senor Barborito 05/27/2003, 8:32am PDT NEW
                        Ok, I give up. NT by NT Helper 05/27/2003, 9:32am PDT NEW
                            You realize I'm trolling you at this point, right? by Senor Barborito 05/27/2003, 9:35am PDT NEW
                                That's why I gave up. by NT Helper 05/27/2003, 9:39am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy