Forum Overview
::
Doom III
::
Re: CGW Comes Out United For Its Doom3 Review.
[quote name="Jeff Green"]This is what happens when I morbidly Google my own name. (And hey, thanks for the compliment on my old column...) I would honestly say we overrated Doom 3 by 1/2 a star. I'd still give it an Editor's Choice (meaning a 4.5) because I still find it an engrossing experience, visually and sonically. Half-Life 2 blows it away in terms of level design, for sure, but HL2 has its own share of problems, IMHO of course. Darren was indeed extremely enthusiastic (duh) in his Doom 3 review. It happens. Not every review by every mag or newspaper nails it every single time. I do think our track record, over the years, is still pretty damn good. But we're not above getting criticism, and we always work on trying to not f*ck up in the future.... Jeff (yes it's really me...you can email me at jeff_green@ziffdavis.com if you want confirmation....)[/quote]