Forum Overview :: Peter Molyneux's The Movies
 
Re: The Special Needs Edition by laudablepuss 12/05/2015, 1:16am PST
A Long, Long Mysterio Ago wrote:

If Star Wars was made by prequel George Lucas
Honestly, I don't think there's a huge divide between the 70s Lucas aside from passion. Everything from the cutting room floor on Tatooine is as boring, plodding, and packed with the same cringe worthy dialogue as the prequels. Earlier forms of the script are terrible too, so it's almost against all odds that Star Wars was able to gel into something coherent in the first place.

The big difference is that later on Lucas was swayed solely by marketability with no oversight. He was also browbeaten over a dozen years into writing scripts and directing films he no longer had the heart for. Maybe George should have sold it off way sooner, or just told FOX to eat shit, I dunno.


I believe it. Maybe still having something to prove back then was part of it too. Who knows. Too bad he's a giant piece of shit now who is SO sorry to tell you that it's just a movie. As if movies were never a passion for him and this whole caring about art thing is weird and unfathomable to him.

Anyway here is an unreadable tract by a bonafide lunatic. See how far you can get!

The author has a strangely selective memory, or deliberately ignores the crazy racist charicatures. He blames all of us for just not giving the movies a chance, even though at the end he lists his own pretty considerable grievences (like R2D2 being able to fly suddenly in the past) with a shrug. Just a movie I guess, why not write a 10k word defense of it *shrug*.

In fact, I was in denial about how terrible the movie was for a few weeks after seeing episode 1 and even wrote a reply to a movie critic explaining why it didn't suck. But I soon realized how awful it was: just watching it again made me queasy. It had nothing to do with the biases and herd mentality that he mentions. I was even still excited for ep 2, wondering if maybe the first one being terrible was a fluke. But no. These are just bad movies, and being angry that the franchise was killed by a feckless imbecile who then is condescending and awful to his fans is a pretty normal reaction.

Maybe jj abrams has brought it back from the dead for some people. But star wars is long over for me. Oh well.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Star Wars: The Very Special Edition. by Mischief Maker 12/04/2015, 2:28pm PST NEW
    Re: Star Wars: The Very Special Edition. by laudablepuss 12/04/2015, 10:18pm PST NEW
    The Special Needs Edition by A Long, Long Mysterio Ago 12/04/2015, 10:49pm PST NEW
        Re: The Special Needs Edition by laudablepuss 12/05/2015, 1:16am PST NEW
            Absolute best cast scenario: Abrams Star Wars = Abrams Star Trek by fabio 12/05/2015, 5:24am PST NEW
                Best case is a little better than that by laudablepuss 12/06/2015, 12:31pm PST NEW
                    That's why I'm hopeful, too. NT by Fullofkittens 12/06/2015, 2:11pm PST NEW
                Likely scenario: Star Wars = the new Star Trek by Vested Id 12/06/2015, 9:47pm PST NEW
                Re: Absolute best cast scenario: Abrams Star Wars = Abrams Star Trek by laudablepuss 12/19/2015, 7:11am PST NEW
            Re: The Special Needs Edition by In a forum far, far away 12/05/2015, 10:56pm PST NEW
        Lucas' ex-wife deserves a lot of credit for cleaning up that original script. NT by Divorce, terrible creative decision 12/05/2015, 7:33am PST NEW
            Tell me about it NT by James Cameron 12/05/2015, 10:11pm PST NEW
                I demand a spot at this table. Divorced in 1989. :( NT by Spielberg 12/05/2015, 10:37pm PST NEW
                    Amateurs. NT by John McTiernan 12/05/2015, 11:47pm PST NEW
        Re: The Special Needs Edition by E. L. Koba 12/05/2015, 12:30pm PST NEW
            I hadn't seen those, holy shit they're terrible NT by Eurotrash 12/06/2015, 12:45pm PST NEW
    Re: Star Wars: The Very Special Edition. by E. L. Koba 12/05/2015, 12:40pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy