Forum Overview :: Someone Review Civ 4 Already
 
A WaPo bitch reporter doesn't bother to do basic research by skip 10/21/2016, 5:49pm PDT
Holy shit, this is pretty egregious. It's a cool enough pop-sci topic. Why do animals sound different in different languages? She interviews one guy who I'm guessing was the article's inspiration.

Derek Abbott, a physicist and electronic engineer at the University of Adelaide in Australia, has compiled one of the largest collections of animal sounds, which he’s put together in a table that you can see here.


And he says:

Abbott said he hasn’t found formal research that addresses this specific topic, and he speculated that “the academic world simply overlooked what was thought to be children’s talk.” But, he continued, “it is loaded with a gold mine of cultural, scientific, and linguistic questions, so definitely deserves study.”


And she just fucking takes his word for it. Not one actual linguist, who may actually know better than an engineer what type of language forms have been studied, was interviewed.

There’s been surprisingly little academic research on this [Update: Or so I thought! After this post was first published, several linguists reached out to let me know that, in fact, there’s been a whole lot of study of onomatopoeia, some of which touches on animal sounds. Read on for input from one of them, Princeton University linguist Byron Ahn].


Of course they had to reach out to you! It's not like it's the job of a reporter to reach out to them for more information. This is something that you could email a local no-name amateur linguist about and they'd probably know. Just leave a comment on a language blog asking if anyone knows about anything about animal noises. It would take less effort than any of the first couple of paragraphs which are all about her FRENCH BILINGUAL CHILDREN. But to just take a guy's word for it because, pfff, he must know, right? That's fucking lazy and I won't pretend it doesn't anger me in a way that most internet bullshit doesn't normally do.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
ITT critics admitting severe knowledge gaps in their field's works by skip 07/01/2014, 8:31pm PDT NEW
    Time to mentioning The Wire: 12 words by skip 07/06/2014, 5:38pm PDT NEW
        I love this series. I wish I had someone to add! NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 07/06/2014, 7:04pm PDT NEW
        I usually like Ruthless by fabio 07/08/2014, 1:14am PDT NEW
            Jesus her twitter by Fabio 07/08/2014, 1:30am PDT NEW
            Re: I usually like Ruthless by Ice Cream Jonsey 07/08/2014, 7:25am PDT NEW
            Her and Dana Stevens don't really have the same problem by skip 07/08/2014, 6:50pm PDT NEW
            More Vandel by fabio 08/16/2014, 3:33am PDT NEW
                A third of all births are c-sections in the US, dumbass. NT by skip 08/16/2014, 12:30pm PDT NEW
                and more Sarah by fabio 08/18/2014, 7:32pm PDT NEW
                I am a self loathing trust fund white person by fabio 09/05/2014, 11:50pm PDT NEW
                    Is it possible to want to punch a paragraph? by fabio 09/06/2014, 12:04am PDT NEW
    I don't understand Pando's purpose by skip 07/11/2014, 10:15pm PDT NEW
        Even worse, Ars did it a year ago by Horrible Gelatinous Blob 07/11/2014, 11:28pm PDT NEW
            Re: Even worse, Ars did it a year ago by Souffle of Pain 07/12/2014, 12:01am PDT NEW
    Ignoring the LGBT characters that hurt your argument by skip 07/24/2014, 6:53pm PDT NEW
        "While it's a little cisnormative" is my favorite Tumblrism by Mysterio Lollerson 10/28/2016, 8:22pm PDT NEW
    A WaPo bitch reporter doesn't bother to do basic research by skip 10/21/2016, 5:49pm PDT NEW
    Bustle offers an alternative reading list by skip 10/01/2017, 6:20am PDT NEW
        Did you just trick me into reading an advertorial? by Injustice 10/01/2017, 10:29am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy