Forum Overview :: Overboard!
 
Lord of the Ring: Fate of the Fellowship - the best new co-cop by Nick Spaz 07/25/2026, 6:40am PDT


Lord of the Rings co-op that's very loosely based on the Pandemic system (mostly Pandemic Fall of Rome). I hate Pandemic, but I love this.

The red orc armies spawn and will move around on those colored pathways. You have to keep them under control and prevent them from overrunning good guy strongholds. Complete 3-4 objective quests, then finally Frodo is open to chuck the ring into Mount Doom.

There's a lot to love here. It organically captures the flow of the movie. There's like 30 total objective quests in the pool, so the random win conditions each game keeps it fresh. Every player gets control of TWO heroes, and can freely pick a "main" one each turn to get 4 actions while the other gets 1, giving everyone lots of flexibility and keeping you from being stuck in a crappy spot with nothing to do.

It usually shapes up by the objectives playing out like the first two books: kill the Balrog, Free Theodan, relieve Minas Tirinth, run around mustering armies from the free peoples, etc. Killing orcs not only keeps them under control, but it draws the attention of the Eye of Sauron and Nazgul, giving Frodo the chance to advance; every movement he makes into orcs or Nazgul makes you roll bad dice that saps Hope, your loss condition resource. There is a huge resource cost to enter Mordor (those little green icons you see along the mountain entrances), so entering is usually a one way trip. A majority of late games have the other characters staging a Black Gate attack to clear the final path for Frodo's end run.

We have yet to play a game where we didn't start playing the climatic music, or a soundboard of lines and Nazgul screams.

We had one weird game where we drew an eagles card, letting us teleport any one character anywhere. A special exception though is dropping Frodo right into Mordor results in every single Nazgul immediately dogpiling him, usually an instant loss (a deliberate nod to the "Why not just fly to Mordor?" argument). Thing is, we found a crazy combo that allowed Gandalf, Eowyn, and Merry+Pippen to wipe all the Nazgul out and actually win by air dropping Frodo right onto Mount Doom.

The basic rules aren't that complex. While not AS simple as Duel for Middle Earth, can still be grasped by casual board gamers (be sure to play on intro difficulty with them). This is a great, casual co-op alternative to the beastly War of the Ring game.
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Lord of the Ring: Fate of the Fellowship - the best new co-cop by Nick Spaz 07/25/2026, 6:40am PDT NEW
    How is it at 2 player? NT by Mischief Maker 07/25/2026, 7:27am PDT NEW
        I've only gone as few as 3 by Nick Spaz 07/25/2026, 8:01am PDT NEW
        Finally played a few 2 player games by Nick Spaz 07/31/2026, 8:08pm PDT NEW
            Okay, after playing a lot more, it's still great at 2 and video guy doesn't know by Nick Spaz 09/03/2026, 2:34pm PDT NEW
        asking him how it is when people come over was the secret NT by understated burn 09/11/2026, 6:27pm PDT NEW
    special mention- whoever designed the box insert & components deserves an award by Nick Spaz 07/25/2026, 8:30am PDT NEW
        special mention- whoever designed the box insert & components deserves an award by Gaige Grosskreutz 09/09/2026, 2:16pm PDT NEW
            Cardboard! You can't even make fun of cardboard now! by Someone give this guy a ride home? 09/09/2026, 9:08pm PDT NEW
                Re: Cardboard! You can't even make fun of cardboard now! by Gaige Grosskreutz 09/09/2026, 9:53pm PDT NEW
                    Man, this guy really likes plastic and cardboard inserts in board game boxes NT by Mysteri-o's 09/10/2026, 3:19am PDT NEW
                    Candyland is too advanced for a 2 year old imo NT by Mysterio 09/10/2026, 6:52am PDT NEW
                    Re: Cardboard! You can't even make fun of cardboard now! by Mischief Maker 09/10/2026, 6:55am PDT NEW
                Re: Cardboard! You can't even make fun of cardboard now! by Gary 09/10/2026, 8:40am PDT NEW
                    nah by Nick Spaz, loud & proud 09/10/2026, 4:23pm PDT NEW
            You're SO JEALOUS of other people contributing content that you can't ^_^ by Nick Spaz 09/10/2026, 4:12pm PDT NEW
                I do like the board game posts. NT by Gaige Grosskreutz 09/10/2026, 5:43pm PDT NEW
                    I was having a bad day yesterday. Sorry, Nick, MM and Lawnmower Man. NT by Gaige Grosskreutz 09/10/2026, 6:02pm PDT NEW
                        Gosh I hope it isn't hormonal, we all now know how that works out for immediate by friends and family 09/11/2026, 6:03pm PDT NEW
                            the real content is getting triggered by small pieces of cardboard by Gaige Grosskreutz 09/11/2026, 6:23pm PDT NEW
                                Yes thank goodness you were here to save us all from danger once again by Several times in just 1 day at that 09/12/2026, 11:09am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy