Forum Overview :: No Stairway to Heaven
 
Re: Method? by NT Fullofkittens 12/05/2004, 5:24pm PST
William H. Hayt, Jr. wrote:

Fussbett wrote:

By saying that Boards of Canada and M83 differ vastly in method and this is one of the three reasons why the two acts cannot be compared implies that if two electronic artists who make electronic music using electronics arrive at the same sound, they still cannot be compared. I think this is not true, if you're wondering. I would readily compare two artists who use vastly different methods, because I don't read Pitchfork enough to know that Band A plays with their feet while Band B does all their recording underwater. All that matters is the final MP3.

Also: Nicolas Fromageau is a good name. Cheese Water!



For the record, I get my instrument information from amg and articles I find, not pitchfork. "Electronics" is no longer a "similiar method" because it has gained so much breadth. Now there are drum machines, hardware synths, software synths, samplers, software arrangement programs, things like fruity loops, etc. A certain combination of these versus another I would consider a different method. What, for example, Prefuse 73 does and Boards of Canada do are totally different even if both use electronic instruments and I wouldn't even attempt to compare them.


That's interesting, because their methods are similar (both using MPCs as sequencers and rhythm modules). I would actually put those two artists (Prefuse 73 and BoC) in the same neighborhood, because they both put an IDM spin on hip-hop beats. They're not *similar*, but they're more like each other than either one is like New Order, for instance.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
m83 is better than Boards of Canada. NT by conflictNo 12/02/2004, 9:33pm PST NEW
    Advance release of their new album is on oink by Ray of Light 12/02/2004, 9:42pm PST NEW
    I disagree with this. by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/02/2004, 10:03pm PST NEW
        Put the apple and the dog in the same room, music man. by conflictNo 12/02/2004, 10:29pm PST NEW
            It's not about sub-genres. by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/02/2004, 11:18pm PST NEW
                Method? by Fussbett 12/05/2004, 3:42am PST NEW
                    Re: Method? by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/05/2004, 1:17pm PST NEW
                        Re: Method? by Fussbett 12/05/2004, 1:53pm PST NEW
                            Re: Method? by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/05/2004, 2:20pm PST NEW
                                Re: Method? by NT Fullofkittens 12/05/2004, 5:24pm PST NEW
                                    Re: Method? by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/05/2004, 5:34pm PST NEW
    Re: m83 is better than Boards of Canada. by akira 12/02/2004, 10:36pm PST NEW
        Oh me! by conflictNo 12/02/2004, 11:06pm PST NEW
    I agree with Hat, there is no relationship between m83 and BoC. (NT) by Fullofkittens 12/02/2004, 11:32pm PST NEW
    Ulrich Schnauss (nt) NT by Monty Cantsin 12/03/2004, 1:19am PST NEW
        This is accurate. NT by William H. Hayt, Jr. 12/03/2004, 1:23am PST NEW
 
powered by pointy