Forum Overview :: No Stairway to Heaven
 
This is a surprise to you? by No Pocky For Titties 06/06/2003, 12:07am PDT
Lizard_King wrote:

MSNBC wrote:

What do bands get from labels? They get a big chunk of change up front when they sign a typical high profile seven-album deal like Pearl Jam did 10 years ago. Everyone likes a large lump sum of money: Debts can be repaid, substantial down payments can be made on cars and houses, drugs can be purchased in bulk at a substantial savings — wait — scratch that.
       But in exchange for that lump sum, the label owns your soul. That lump sum isn’t a payment, it’s a loan against which recording, promotion, and publicity costs — virtually all costs — are charged. A band doesn’t start receiving royalties, real “earned” money, until it pays back that loan with sales, or “recoups.”
Pearl Jam tour satisfies pent-up demand
       Very few artists ever recoup and earn royalties — as Pearl Jam has undoubtedly done — and even when they do recoup, artists don’t receive ownership of their own master recordings. As attorney Freundlich puts it, “The old adage is, it’s like paying off your mortgage but never owning your house.”


Hopefully this will work out more successfully than their anti-Ticketmaster crusade, or for that matter their Nader-cheering.


Yet another reason why this site needs a search feature: I wrote virtually this same article months ago in this very forum. What's surprising about major labels is not that they screw artists - that's their fucking JOB. The surprising thing is that musicians (who are, at some level, all independent business people) are so willing to ride ass-first on major label cock. I took a workshop at one point on running an independent label (unsurprisingly, kind of a ripoff, but still valuable), and the one point that really hit home which the guy made was: if a record label wants to put out your record, it's because they can make money off of you. They aren't interested in your career. All they want is ALL YOUR MONEY. If you give it to them it's your own fucking fault - you should have hired your own lawyer. I don't feel bad for artists that get screwed, they fuck themselves over.

The royalties agreements are negotiable. The touring agreements are negotiable. This shit is all negotiable. If you say that you own your masters, if they want you bad enough, you'll get them. If you're afraid that you won't pay back your advance - TURN DOWN THE FUCKING ADVANCE!!!

Good example: Jawbox left respectable indie Dischord and defected to Atlantic during the post-Nirvana We Need The Next Nirvana era. In the process, they alienated most of their fans, but they actually got a much better contract with Atlantic than they'd had with Dischord - they stipulated that they'd own their masters, and they refused touring support (since they didn't want the label touching their primary source of income). They used Atlantic's marketing money to get their name in front of zillions of teenagers, and got semi-popular. Then they got screwed in that their label subsidiary closed down and they were dropped, right after possibly their best album came out. So, they broke up - but the real end of the story was that because they're not idiots, they negotiated their contract correctly and were able to start their own indie label (DeSoto) with profits from their now-out-on-Desoto Jawbox catalogue. Now they (or, some of they) make their living running the label and producing.

Another good example: Beck has major-label records and indie-label records. I'm sure he makes more from his indies per-unit than he does on his major label records. It would be interesting to see where the bulk of Beck's money comes from.

FoK Titties
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Despite the fact that nobody cares about Pearl Jam, this is interesting . . . by Senor Barborito 06/05/2003, 2:22pm PDT NEW
    Hard to believe sometimes how badly record labels screw artists. by Lizard_King 06/05/2003, 6:47pm PDT NEW
        This is a surprise to you? by No Pocky For Titties 06/06/2003, 12:07am PDT NEW
            I guess not. Thanks for the elaboration. by Lizard_King 06/12/2003, 9:31pm PDT NEW
                Re: I guess not. Thanks for the elaboration. by FoK 06/12/2003, 11:42pm PDT NEW
                    Man, I hated the Verve Pipe. And the Verve, for that matter. by Lizard_King 06/14/2003, 1:28pm PDT NEW
                    Re: I guess not. Thanks for the elaboration. by jeep 06/16/2003, 5:27pm PDT NEW
                        That is fucked up. Although Reznor deserves it, I guess. NT by Lizard_King 06/16/2003, 8:43pm PDT NEW
                            ...why? by FoK 06/17/2003, 12:57am PDT NEW
                                Re: ...why? by Lizard_King 06/17/2003, 11:33am PDT NEW
                                Re: ...why? by Trent Reznor 06/17/2003, 8:01pm PDT NEW
                                    Re: ...why? by Lizard_King 06/17/2003, 8:29pm PDT NEW
                                        Re: ...why? by FoK 06/17/2003, 8:34pm PDT NEW
                                            hmm... by Lizard_King 06/17/2003, 9:20pm PDT NEW
                                                One minute. Fucker. NT by creativepig 06/17/2003, 9:22pm PDT NEW
                                            Re: ...why? by creativepig 06/17/2003, 9:21pm PDT NEW
                                                Re: ...why? by FoK 06/17/2003, 9:33pm PDT NEW
                        In the case of Tool: see "A Perfect Circle" by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 1:58am PDT NEW
                            Re: In the case of Tool: see "A Perfect Circle" by Fussbett 06/17/2003, 8:01am PDT NEW
                                Re: In the case of Tool: see "A Perfect Circle" by FoK 06/17/2003, 8:09am PDT NEW
                                Wrong by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 8:32am PDT NEW
                                    You're wrong about OpenBSD, computers. by Fussbett 06/17/2003, 8:53am PDT NEW
                                        Heh, bzzzt by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 9:11am PDT NEW
                                            Nope, I'm still right. by Fussbett 06/17/2003, 9:33am PDT NEW
                                                Re: Nope, I'm still right. by FoK 06/17/2003, 9:42am PDT NEW
                                                Re: Nope, I'm still right. by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 10:11am PDT NEW
                                                    Sisters of Mercy by FoK 06/17/2003, 10:24am PDT NEW
                                                    Re: Nope, I'm still right. by Jhoh Creexul 06/17/2003, 10:42am PDT NEW
                                                        Barring their second to last CD I'd agree NT by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 10:47am PDT NEW
                                                            Tool live blows APC out of the water, hands down. NT by Lizard_King 06/17/2003, 11:35am PDT NEW
                                                                Haven't had the fortune of seeing Tool, so I can't comment by Senor Barborito 06/17/2003, 11:36am PDT NEW
                                                                    Re: Haven't had the fortune of seeing Tool, so I can't comment by Lizard_King 06/17/2003, 1:41pm PDT NEW
                            See both, and ignore him by Bill Dungsroman 06/17/2003, 12:20pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy