Forum Overview :: Motherfucking News
 
Re: It's true by I need clarification 02/25/2006, 1:22pm PST
Reichsminister Doktor Goebbels wrote:

motherfuckerfoodeater wrote:

It's true that the unwashed masses tend to be "against abortion" in some vague way, but would never put any teeth behind their "eww gross" reaction. This whole 5 years with no exceptions thing is definitely not going to go down well with the nation at large, and I suspect that even filthy ignorant South-Dekotans will end up feeling pretty negative about it.


Whether pro-life advocates would actually stand behind their talk isn't relevant to whether it's democratic or not. From early in the 20th Century until the late 1960s conducting abortions was a crime in all 50 states. When Roe was handed down, abortion was legal on demand in 4 states and available with various qualifications in 13 others, while it was still highly restricted in the remaining states. This regime was a product of voter choice, mostly through state legislature elections, but also through a handful of referenda. Then nine men chosen at the whim of president, including one appointed during the FDR administration, stepped in and decided the people weren't entitled to make the decision.


At the WHIM of the president!! How dare he!!

They were also vetted and approved by the congress, which was elected by the people, including those in South Dakota.

Anyway, we're not talking about a democracy where every decision is left to the (whim of the) people. We're talking about the USA, which takes its governmental structure from the constitution, which provides for a Supreme Court, which has the power to act against the alleged will of the majority. And sometimes does, whether the individual represenatives of the populace like it or not.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Progressive-thinking South Dakota first to attempt abortion ban by Fussbett 02/23/2006, 4:41am PST NEW
    Re: Progressive-thinking South Dakota first to attempt abortion ban by Fullofkittens 02/23/2006, 6:59am PST NEW
        I've never heard of that, I think she must have made it up for a laugh :( NT by One of QT3's many Doctors 02/23/2006, 12:20pm PST NEW
        FullofDeadKittens NT by MM 02/23/2006, 3:46pm PST NEW
    I also think that we should reopen the black market on abortions. by Mysterio 02/23/2006, 9:41am PST NEW
        Prepare to be satiated. NT by Chairman Mao 02/23/2006, 10:21am PST NEW
            Wow, with ZINGERs like that why the fuck did you ever leave? NT by Quenty McBeck 02/24/2006, 8:34am PST NEW
                DURR FAG NT NT NT by Chairman Mao 02/24/2006, 9:08am PST NEW
                    PREPARING FOR SATIATION! NT by Quenty McBeck 02/24/2006, 12:39pm PST NEW
    Re: Progressive-thinking South Dakota first to attempt abortion ban by Reichsminister Doktor Goebbels 02/24/2006, 7:42pm PST NEW
        Re: Progressive-thinking South Dakota first to attempt abortion ban by Souffle of Pain 02/24/2006, 9:28pm PST NEW
        This is actually patently untrue by motherfuckerfoodeater 02/24/2006, 9:34pm PST NEW
            Re: It's true by Reichsminister Doktor Goebbels 02/24/2006, 11:18pm PST NEW
                Ever hear of the phrase "tyranny of the majority"? by Coronation 02/25/2006, 1:09am PST NEW
                Re: It's true by I need clarification 02/25/2006, 1:22pm PST NEW
                    Re: It's true by Reichsminister Doktor Goebbels 02/25/2006, 1:45pm PST NEW
                        Re: It's true by Fussbett 02/25/2006, 3:17pm PST NEW
                            intricacies NT by Fussbett 02/25/2006, 3:17pm PST NEW
                        On second reading, I realize your post took no position at all. Apologies. :) NT by I need clarification 02/25/2006, 3:23pm PST NEW
                ZSENI NT by DAHLING 02/25/2006, 7:11pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy