Forum Overview :: Review Requests!
 
Oh wow I thought the safe space thing was hyperbole by nope! 01/11/2025, 1:56am PST
Nope, right from the start you outright get main story objectives with your social anxiety main character running to go pout in his bedroom. Multiple characters come up to explain to you how this is a safe space where everyone can share their feelings and power of friendship. You are forced into movie night with totally a film nerd manic pixie girl who launches straight into daddy issues.

There's a genre of novels called "cozy mysteries". It's for senior women who think Murder She Wrote had too much conflict and violence. They're supposed to be murder mysteries, but 95% of the plot is mundane routines of the protagonist running a bakery, or boring mundane conversations about what they did on their last vacation cruise, or boring mundane gossip about the grandkids of every acquaintance in town. They're known for being deathly allergic to any kind of tension. When any kind of conflict or danger is introduced, it's immediately dispelled within 3 whole paragraphs. Murderers and mafia hitmen are toothless against local bakers and quilting circles.

That's what came to mind as I played this. They had a chance at a minimal amount of pathos with the main character. You wake up from a centuries long coma. Your MILF mentor is now an old bag, and your bestie comrade is dead, incinerated in an accident trying to teach Scarlet Witch to control her powers. This could be the source of some kind of sorrow, grieving, or resentment toward Wanda. Everything was torn away from your character and you never got any chance to say goodbye.

Except you immediately walk up to your bestie's grave and she comes back as a ghost and right out of the gate takes the same Joss Whedon "allergic to sincerity" quirky Marvel cookie cutter dialog tone as every other character. "No big deal. I like being a dead ghost more than I did being alive, so there's no need to worry or be mad at Wanda. Let's swap some quips." Pathos immediately dispelled! Do you want to debate zombie movies at the next hangout?

There's probably half a dozen X-MEN arcs that would have worked better for this safe space hideout setting. I have no idea why they went with one where half the cast are centuries old immortals who have seen all kinds of shit and witch hunts and genocides and wars and Lovecraftian horrors, yet talk to each other like everyone is the mental health counselor at the most coddled private university.

This writing is SO bad. It's Bioware meets Marvel and the writers don't have the talent to clear the low bar for either.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Midnight Suns? NT by Wonder Wifu 12/13/2022, 3:26pm PST NEW
    SKIP by E. L. Koba 12/14/2022, 2:21pm PST NEW
        The dialog seems very Bioware by Wonder Waifu 12/15/2022, 2:55pm PST NEW
        Give it to us, Koba! NT by We want BLOOD 10/13/2023, 12:14am PDT NEW
            I had a very rough draft wrote, but then saw the Yatzee review which was better by E. L. Koba 12/21/2023, 10:57am PST NEW
                Awesome! by We want BLOOD! 12/22/2023, 10:51am PST NEW
                    Re: Awesome! by E. L. Koba 12/27/2023, 4:18pm PST NEW
                Oh wow I thought the safe space thing was hyperbole by nope! 01/11/2025, 1:56am PST NEW
        Koba! NT by What's yer steam handle? 01/11/2025, 11:09pm PST NEW
            elkoba NT by E. L. Koba 01/16/2025, 3:34pm PST NEW
    It was okay for the price. NT by Oh I thought this was CRYING Suns 10/13/2023, 6:41am PDT NEW
        UHHHHH SOOOOOOOOOOOO THAT HAPPENED NT by Mysterio 03/07/2024, 10:00am PST NEW
            fuck u NT by Thonk 03/07/2024, 11:47am PST NEW
            Crying Suns is great, what's your problem? by hope they fix it 04/10/2024, 12:49pm PDT NEW
                It's alpha version FTL with gorgeous art by Tux sux 04/11/2024, 1:02am PDT NEW
    Free on Epic games store NT by So THAT just happened! 06/06/2024, 10:12pm PDT NEW
        First 5 hours by So THAT just happened! 06/15/2024, 5:34am PDT NEW
            Re: First 5 hours by Mysterio 06/15/2024, 9:59am PDT NEW
                I tried to warn ya'll NT by E. L. Koba 06/15/2024, 11:58am PDT NEW
                    It was free! by So THAT just happened! 06/15/2024, 12:39pm PDT NEW
                        Every time I see your nick, I laugh. Post moar pleeze NT by carl 06/15/2024, 6:48pm PDT NEW
                    Did you ever finish it? NT by Finish him! 06/15/2024, 5:23pm PDT NEW
                more numbers by Number Man (Wacky intro caption!) 06/16/2024, 4:54am PDT NEW
                    I have kinda seen that combat system before though by Number Man (The NSFW poster!) 06/16/2024, 9:15am PDT NEW
                    Okay seriously what is with this resource hogging by Number Man (Wacky intro caption!) 06/16/2024, 6:09pm PDT NEW
            Re: First 5 hours by Eury 06/16/2024, 7:17am PDT NEW
            I completely forgot I had this by So THAT just happened! 06/30/2024, 6:03am PDT NEW
    This entire thread is great. by Mechapaw 07/03/2024, 8:41am PDT NEW
        *moves mechapaw to mechacock* NT by THAT is what caltrops is about 07/03/2024, 6:04pm PDT NEW
            thanks Geryk NT by great post, A+ 07/03/2024, 6:06pm PDT NEW
                another example of the worthlessness of that garbage NT by Start over 01/11/2025, 8:54am PST NEW
                    I'll stink you good NT by Gary 01/11/2025, 9:41am PST NEW
                        Will you two just fuck already and get this over with? NT by Mischief Maker 01/11/2025, 3:56pm PST NEW
    $9 on Steam sale by Ice Cream Jonsey 12/23/2024, 7:54pm PST NEW
        FREE wasn't fair! NT by it's so bad 12/24/2024, 7:45am PST NEW
    Every time someone says, "Safe place" by Drinking game 01/15/2025, 4:08am PST NEW
        Also you can send teammates away to therapy NT by Drinking game 01/15/2025, 4:13am PST NEW
        Re: Every time someone says, "Safe place" by Ice Cream Jonsey 01/15/2025, 9:41am PST NEW
            ha ha ha ha ha by Drinking game 01/15/2025, 11:49am PST NEW
                Re: ha ha ha ha ha by E. L. Koba 01/16/2025, 3:46pm PST NEW
                    On top of that, the player character is the blandest hero imaginable by Drinking game 01/17/2025, 1:40am PST NEW
                        They even got the worst voice actors to do the male/female protagonist NT by Yuna from FF10 all over again 01/17/2025, 4:08am PST NEW
        Re: Every time someone says, "Safe place" by E. L. Koba 01/16/2025, 3:42pm PST NEW
            This thing is outright trolling me now by Drinking game 01/17/2025, 1:21am PST NEW
 
powered by pointy